If this game does turn out to be what Sgea claims it to be, I'm curious if they're going to treat it like a new game entirely or make it as a sort of tribute to the Genesis days sort of in the same vein of what Bionic Commando Rearmed did for the original Nes game. I think a lot of the presentational choices made will hinge on this choice. The fan in me actually hopes they go the tribute route.
What about Sonic Labyrinth? I always figured that to be the worst.... Though I guess since it is a Spin Off it doesn't count...
I still think Sonic '06 is worse. Yes, if I had to choose to play one of those games I would choose Sonic Labyrinth. '06 is just that bad.